Hi,
Hi, sorry for the very late review. See the comments below: On Mon, 2017-08-28 at 17:32 +0200, Jonatan Schlag wrote:The valid options for a host-to-net ipsec connection and a net-to-net are different so we nedd to check if we get a valid option for the connection type. Fixes: #11444 Signed-off-by: Jonatan Schlag <jonatan.schlag@ipfire.org> --- src/functions/functions.ipsec | 129 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 129 insertions(+) diff --git a/src/functions/functions.ipsec b/src/functions/functions.ipsec index 6f14c8e..11a1d9a 100644 --- a/src/functions/functions.ipsec +++ b/src/functions/functions.ipsec @@ -54,6 +54,46 @@ IPSEC_DEFAULT_TYPE="net-to-net" IPSEC_VALID_MODES="gre-transport tunnel vti" IPSEC_VALID_AUTH_MODES="PSK" +# Valid options for all types of connetions +IPSEC_ALL_VALID_OPTIONS="\ + authentication \ + down \ + disable \ + dpd \ + enable \ + inactivity_timeout \ + local \ + mode \ + remote \ + security_policy \ + start_action \ + up \ + color \ + description \ + show"Could we order those alphabetically?+ +# Valid options for net-to-net +IPSEC_NET_TOT_NET_VALID_OPTIONS="${IPSEC_ALL_VALID_OPTIONS} \ + peer"I think it should be "TO" in the variable name. You could also use "N2N" to make it a little bit shorter maybe.+ +# Valid options for RW +IPSEC_RW_VALID_OPTIONS="${IPSEC_ALL_VALID_OPTIONS} \ + pool" + +# Valid dpd options for all types of connetions +IPSEC_DPD_ALL_VALID_OPTIONS="\ + delay \ + timeout" + +# Valid dpd options for net-to-net +IPSEC_DPD_NET_TOT_NET_VALID_OPTIONS="${IPSEC_DPD_ALL_VALID_OPTIONS} \ + action"Same as above.+ +# Valid dpd options for RW +IPSEC_DPD_RW_VALID_OPTIONS="${IPSEC_DPD_ALL_VALID_OPTIONS}" + + +Three lines of whitespace. One should do.cli_ipsec() { local action=${1} shift 1 @@ -79,6 +119,10 @@ cli_ipsec_connection() { key=${key//-/_} shift 2 + if ! ipsec_connection_check_option "${connection}" "first" "${key}"; then + return ${EXITR_ERROR} + fi +Typo in the EXIT_ERROR variable.case "${key}" in authentication|down|disable|dpd|enable|inactivity_tim eout|local|mode|peer|pool|remote|security_policy|start_action|up) ipsec_connection_${key} ${connection} "$@" @@ -148,6 +192,67 @@ ipsec_connection_get_description_title() { description_title_read $(description_format_filename "ipsec- connection" "${name}") } +# This functions returns all options which are valid for this type of connection +ipsec_get_valid_options() { + assert [ $# -eq 2 ] + + local connection="${1}" + local type="${2}" + + local con_type=$(ipsec_connection_get_type "${connection}") + assert isset con_type + + case ${con_type} in + host-to-net) + case ${type} in + first) + echo "${IPSEC_RW_VALID_OPTIONS}" + ;; + dpd) + echo "${IPSEC_DPD_RW_VALID_OPTIONS}" + ;; + esac + ;; + net-to-net) + case ${type} in + first) + echo "${IPSEC_NET_TOT_NET_VALID_OPTIONS}" + ;; + dpd) + echo "${IPSEC_DPD_NET_TOT_NET_VALID_OPTIONS}" + ;; + esac + ;; + esac +} + +# This Function checks if a option is valid for a given type +ipsec_connection_check_option() { + assert [ $# -eq 3 ] + + local connection="${1}" + local type="${2}" + local key="${3}" + + local con_type=$(ipsec_connection_get_type "${connection}") + assert isset con_type + + case ${con_type} in + host-to-net) + if ! isoneof key $(ipsec_get_valid_options "${connection}" "${type}"); then + log ERROR "Invalid Argument: ${key}" + return ${EXIT_ERROR} + fi + ;; + net-to-net) + if ! isoneof key $(ipsec_get_valid_options "${connection}" "${type}"); then + log ERROR "Invalid Argument: ${key}" + return ${EXIT_ERROR} + fi + ;; + esac +} + cli_ipsec_connection_show() { local connection="${1}" @@ -443,6 +548,26 @@ ipsec_reload() { ipsec_strongswan_load } +# Returns the type of a connection +ipsec_connection_get_type() { + assert [ $# -eq 1 ] + + local connection=${1} + + if ! ipsec_connection_exists "${connection}"; then + log ERROR "No such VPN ipsec connection: ${connection}" + return ${EXIT_ERROR} + fiIt is called a "IPsec VPN connection". IPsec is spelled like this and the rest sounds like Yoda :)+ + local TYPE + + if ! ipsec_connection_read_config "${connection}" TYPE; then + return ${EXIT_ERROR} + fi + + echo ${TYPE} +} + # Handle the cli after authentification ipsec_connection_authentication() { if [ ! $# -gt 1 ]; then @@ -551,6 +676,10 @@ ipsec_connection_dpd() { local cmd=${2} shift 2 + if ! ipsec_connection_check_option "${connection}" "dpd" "${cmd}"; then + return ${EXITR_ERROR} + fi +Should the user not get a better message when DPD commands are not available?
case ${cmd} in action) ipsec_connection_dpd_action "${connection}" "$@"-Michael